Friday, 28 February 2014

Portrayal of Women

“Dear, you can not become a police officer,” said my mother. There were thousands of questions raised in my head later on finding out her opinion on this. Is this because I am a girl and the society believes that the males are much stronger than the females, and us women are not capable of doing such hard work? If this is the case then I am totally against these stereotypes of masculinity and femininity. My father has always praised me in doing what I desire to do. He has been a great backbone of mine as he said, “Make sure you succeed in what you aim for, and most importantly succeed in what you are interested in getting,” until my mother stepped in and shared her views on occupations which females are suitable for and the ones which only males are suitable for as the media depicts. Instead of encouraging and believing in what I can do for my nation and family as an honest police officer, my mother disinclined from becoming one due to what the media and the society tells us about femininity.

Everyone dreams to achieve their goals, yet not all of them come with a guarantee that it will turn into a reality. Some people go through a lot of pain and puts in plenty of effort to approach towards their dream, while others might not even have to face high troubles to achieve it. When dreams shatter before even approaching in it due to the inequality between males and females, I clearly envision the loss of the patriots, hard workers, intelligent, and the passionate people to many countries. 



"When I was born, they looked at me and said: 'What a good boy, what a smart boy, what a strong boy!' And when you were born, they looked at you and said:'What a good girl, what a smart girl, what a pretty girl!’"

According to the media, women’s role falls into either as housewives or mothers. They represent women’s role to be smaller and less than males. As we have noted, women are less likely to be in the headlines of the news stories such as, business, law, and politics due to the patriarchal attitude of the society. When a baby girl is born, the expressions which we usually use are, “Aw, she is so pretty”. There are hence many other stereotypes that represent females, which can lead them to stop from getting or doing something. Such stereotypes are, women are weak, women are the housewife, and women are sex symbols.

“Women are weak”

From television to even movies, they continue to represent women as weak creatures who are emotional to the extent, scared, and powerless. It is often said that women are dependent on men in texts like the Twilight series. The main female character, Bella, was mentioned in the book as a weak and defenceless person fenced by strong and powerful male characters. Films such as, Final Destination, Scream, Last house on the Left, and Paranormal Activity Series are examples of females who were targeted for the brutal treatment. Females are usually pressured, chased, and threatened before the men in horror films. Such movies and texts influence our society and persuade their point of views to ours. In the workplaces, men have greater chances of being in the high position than the women who are secured in a position as secretaries. Long time ago, when women first took a step to help their male members in the house, many of their jobs weren’t skilled and didn't have a high income but they proved to be a valuable point. Women proved that their perspective is equally important as men and demonstrated beyond doubt that they belonged in society’s growing job market with pride. This proved that women began to become more independent and not reliant on the men. The roles of women as an independent were seen in the movies Tangled and Brave. Ultimately, they are not just represented as mothers in the society, media, and text, but they're likewise known as well employed workers in high office.
















“Women are the housewife”

The major roles of women in the society are cooking for their families, taking care of children, and cleaning their house. Sometimes women have no option but to be stuck at home due to their religious/cultural influence and educational influence. Following ads imply discrimination.














“Women are sex symbols”

Male, female, actor, actress, or a model can be known for their sexual appeal who is especially a famous person. As women in this case, sex symbol naturally implies the assumption that she is brainless; “Beauty with no brains”. Ads are becoming more explicit and using women’s body to sexualize it. To capture the audiences’ attention, ads display women’s half naked body to get their brand popular and make profit out of it. Examples of these brands would be Victoria’s Secret and Hanes. There is a big change occurred in the media of the female sex symbol over the time. The change impacts on the society and causes female to be less important than male in intellectual terms. After all these cases we can easily tell what the media and society portraits about female. Famous female and women in our society are stereotyped and depicted in the media as a sex symbol and known to be good for only sex. 




















The following video is about female on magazine covers and posters in the celebrity world which highly impacts on our society and the media.



My question to you guys are:

Do you personally think female themselves are causing such stereotypes of a sex symbol in the media and the society?

What do you think about the stereotypes and the portrayal about female?

What is your opinion on patriarchal society?

If you were to represent female in one sentence, what would you say?

Which of the stereotypes do you agree with and disagree with? Explain.



Thursday, 27 February 2014

The representation of males in the media and our society.


The Society

The representation of males varies from place to place. However, I think in most of the societies; males are represented as bread winners, protectors and leaders. Whenever I have visited my grand relatives, I have noticed that my grandfather or my granduncle did all the chores such as shoveling the snow, cutting the grass, fixing a bulb, etc. They did all the chores which required physical strength.They are from that typical era, where men did all the, "manly jobs" and let the women do the "basic housewife jobs", such as cooking food, raising children, washing clothes, etc. These representations of men, have been passed down from the beginning of the civilization, and I believe it is still being passed down to the next generation. From the beginning of civilization and even till now at many places around the world; males are considered to be a superior gender, regardless of their drawbacks. For instance, during 'World War' women were banned from fighting during the war. The military would not recruit any females, as fighting in the war was considered to be way above their "place". I come from a patriarchal society, where this ideology of gender superiority is very evident. When I immigrated to Canada, the equality of men and women at this high level was really eye catching and astonishing to me. I wondered why the gender equality of men and women does not exist in other countries,  as much as it exists in Canada. Many questions arose in my mind regarding the existence of gender inequality and the representations of men in certain societies. 


The Media



 The media is a medium through which all the representations and stereotypes of males are passed on to public and the next generation. 

The following video shows how 'Disney movies' (media)  pass on stereotypes and ideologies of gender inequality to the next generation. 

 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5oyGGwjPbLw


The media represented males as "macho" characters back at the era of the early 1900's. However, the "macho" trait did not last for long. I believe that new representations of males were developed by the media as the process of minimizing of gender inequality slowly began during the 1980's. New representations such as, "The violent hero", "The hilarious hero", and "The dominating hero" were established. There were changes in the representation of males' appearance in the media overtime as well. Men used to appear more dominant and sleek, and now they appear more muscular, attractive and lean. The disappearance of the "macho" (dominating) attire overtime is an evidence of societies leading to gender equality and establishing a non- patriarchal society.

Questions

1) Do you know any other representations of men in the media and in our society?
2) Do you have any family members who follows the ideology of gender superiority?
3) Do you guys know in which parts of the world gender inequality has become fatal to women?
4) Do you wish to live in a patriarchal society or a non- patriarchal society? Why?
5) Do you ever think that males and females will have similar portrayal of their representations in media and in our society?












Sunday, 23 February 2014

Spare the rod, spoil the child

I vividly remember  I had cheated on a test in Pakistan when I was young . My teacher apparently  found out when a fellow student told on me and she told me to walk in front of the class. "Bring forth your hands", she ordered. My body shook with fear--so much fear that I didn't dare meet my eyes with hers. I shakingly took out my tiny hands, palms facing up. "Flip you hands", she ordered. Right there, I knew what was about to happen next; tears flooded my eyes. I rapidly closed my eyes tight and for the next few seconds I could hear the stick whooshing by my ears and then the immense pain that followed after. I yelled and I cried. When I opened my eyes, my hands were bleeding.

Why do I still remember this event 10 years later? This is because this event shaped me as a child--scared, shy, and a quiet girl I became. The teacher punishing me so rigorously bought so much fear and pain into my heart that I isolated myself from other people. I thought that I couldn't trust anyone anymore and that no one loved me. I was certainly depressed. Did I learn anything from this punishment? No. I  merely learned to fear the world.
A common punishment given to students who disobey teachers

"Spare the rod, spoil the child"
This is a common expression used by many people who support corporal punishment. It is a very common belief that if a child is not given punishment, the child will not learn and will become spoiled. Therefore, the child must be taught by "tough love".

There are many common ways of corporal punishment:
-paddling (using a paddle to hit)
-spanking (an action of smacking on the buttocks)
-hitting with a stick on the hands

Using such methods leaves a lot of scars, scars that may take a lot of time to fade or may not even fade. As a child it took me so much time to recover from the stigma of being beaten front of the class. However, when I came to Canada, I met new friends and caring teachers whom really helped me get over my fears.
Some bruises may disappear, but what about the scars that will be carried onto the rest of their adult lives?

 My Ideology
There is a saying, "Darkness cannot drive out darkness; only light can do that. Hate cannot drive out hate; only love can do that". Children cannot be disciplined by infliction of pain or violence; but rather love. In an environment where new leaders, readers, writers, scientists are born should not be place of hate and violence--but rather love and light. Therefore, I personally believe that children can effectively be taught a lesson by love. This is through my personal experience.  To back up my ideology, studies show that corporal punishment on children has many long term negative effects. That is, they suffer from anxiety, depression and many other mental issues. In fact, children become more aggressive and this aggressiveness can be carried into their own adulthood lives. This makes sense to me because what right does a parent/teacher have to teach a child to not to practice violence when they themselves are practicing it? What are they really teaching their children? Hate and violence. Not love and knowledge.

(source:http://healthland.time.com/2012/10/01/should-teachers-spank-students-a-texas-school-district-expands-its-corporal-punishment-policy/)

This video is a short animation which shows different forms of corporal punishment that students experience. It also promotes the idea that corporal punishment must be stopped.
 

This video is about corporal punishment being banned in Barbados due to its ineffectiveness. In fact, Winter Pilgrim(a teacher in the school) also describes how his relationship with his daughter deteriorated as he used corporal punishment to discipline her.

 

End Note:
We all come from different cultures, where corporal punishment may be practiced or not. However, I'd really like to hear some different opinions from you guys even if its opposing my ideology. In fact, I'd like to share my story--I come from a rural region of Pakistan where corporal punishment is quite common at home and at school. In the cities, it's not common. My mom  even spanked me quite a few times when I was a child (it was painful!). Recently, I sat down and discussed this issue with my parents, and their remark was "The child becomes spoiled. Hurmain, a tree that doesn't bend by the wind breaks"

I am going to rest my case here everybody. Here are some questions I want you guys to reflect upon:

1. Have you ever experienced any form of corporal punishment? How did you feel?
2. Do you personally think corporal punishment is effective?
3.Why do some parents/teachers still use corporal punishment when they know its not effective? Philosophically, why do many people practice corporal punishment so much that its become a of part our culture?
6. What alternative methods can we use to teach children the lessons without being violent?






Sunday, 9 February 2014

Man Up!


My four year old son cries easily. When he was in daycare and pre-school, his providers would give us frequent reports on how he cried over one thing or another. His very first JK school report card had the comment "he should continue to manage his emotions". When he was really young,  I didn't mind his tears; I know how important it is for men to express their feelings and I was determined that my son would feel free to express his emotions.  But over the years, and now that he's almost five, I notice myself telling him to be a "big boy" and not cry unless he's really hurt.  His dad does the same. 

 I find myself secretly pleased that he likes to play fight with his friend in the school yard or that he loves superheroes or that he's fearless in goals at soccer. Because the truth is, I worry that he might be perceived as a "crybaby" by his peers. The truth is, although I want a sensitive, empathetic, artistic, kind son, I also want him to be a tough little boy. In other words, without explicitly saying so, I want him to "man up."

The Urban Dictionary defines "man up" as:


Don't be a pussy, brave it, be daring.
"Hey man, finish this bowl."
"No dude, I'm baked as it is."
"Come on pussy, man up."
by a dizzle pizzle June 21, 2003
(http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=man+up)
You know the expression, synonymous with "grow some balls," "suck it up," or "don't be such a pussy." It just occurred to me last semester that actually, the worst thing a man can be called is a woman.
This expectation that boys be "a real man" is pervasive. I hear it in the halls and classrooms of Kipling, day in and day out. "You're a pussy." "You're a fag." 
But I've never really thought about what it must feel like as a boy,  to have to wake up each morning and have to think about the mask you are going to wear when you walk out the door. 

The trailer for the forthcoming film, The Mask You Live In,  is part of "The Representation Project" (http://therepresentationproject.org/mask) also responsible for the documentary Miss Representation, about the misrepresentation of females in the media.  The filmmaker, like me, has a son and wants to "explore how our culture's narrow definition of masculinity" is harming our boys, men and society at large" (http://therepresentationproject.org/mask)
plore 




The video asks the question, how are we raising our boys? And how is how we are raising our boys harming them? How strong do they have to be to stand up to the pressure of "man up?"  How many boys and men ever do stand up for their right to feel and express how they feel?

The spoken word piece, "Action" by the artist Guante does just that. In it, he gives 10 responses to the words "man up". 








http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Lv3akBYZrRo


So, I guess I need to do some soul searching and talk to my husband about how (even subtly) we are teaching our son to "man up". Because I don't want him to have to put a mask on to walk out our door, or even worse, have to wear a mask for us, his parents. I don't 
want him to be someone he isn't.

I have some questions for you:


  • Guys, do you feel the pressure to man up? If so, how?
  • Girls, in what way(s) do you contribute to this definition of masculinity?  
  • Where in the media have you seen the message of "man up"? Either explicitly or implicitly?
  • Why aren't guys allowed to be more emotional or expressive? Where does this idea come from? What are we scared of?
  • What needs to change? Or rather, where should the change start?



 our culture’s narrow definition of masculinity is harming our boys, men, and society at large. - See more at: http://therepresentationproject.org/mask#sthash.o2QgD2U9.dpufxplore how our culture’s narrow definition of masculinity is harming our boys, men, and society at large. - See more at: http://therepresentationproject.org/mask#sthash.o2QgD2U9.dpuexplore how our culture’s narrow definition of masculinity is harming our boys, men, and society at large. - See more at: http://therepresentationproject.org/mask#sthash.o2QgD2U9.dpuf