Monday, 12 May 2014

Women are nurses, not doctors


Gender stereotypes are really becoming an issue in our society nowadays. I come from a family and from a religion that allows men and women to be seen as equals. Of course the men have a little more say than the women but thats just how our religion entails us to do. The issue that concerns me most that has become a more popular topic in recent years is that women aren't doctors, only nurses. There are many people that would say that they disagree or agree with this statement but let me share my points. I definitely disagree not because its a false statement but because I have seen myself some of the more intelectual people in our society. Even in the past we see many professors and doctors that have been mainly women that have done some great things. Take Marie Curie for example. she was the first woman to get 2 nobel prizes in 2 different categories. She did this during a time when women weren't even allowed to be doctors or scientists.

The “doctor-nurse game”, as described by Stein in 1967, was an oppressive tradition built on a long-standing historical relationship. Stein concluded that both professions would do well to eradicate this “transactional neurosis”. Male doctors continue to hold the more prestigious and powerful jobs.
 this is just how its been since the dawn of man. Since men are seen as the more brave and powerful figure they should be the ones who should be doctors. women on the other hand are smart yet gentle so they should be the nurses. 




http://www.ehow.co.uk/video_4951255_gender-discrimination-lead-stereotypes_.html

this link will lead you to a very informative video on gender discrimination and how women are treated as a part of it.



 The healthcare field as was know it traditionally was run by male physicians and female nurses. Dating back to the 1800′s.

Overtime however people gradually started to develop the understanding that men aren't the only ones that are capable of doing difficult jobs. Some people might think it depends on where you are on earth, this could mean that the men feel more responsible to take care of their families.

Women must also see to it that they do not respond to stereotypes with counter productive behaviours . Instead, women should demonstrate their effectiveness in these roles, and in time they will prove these stereotypes false.

here are a few questions:


  • Have you ever mistaken a male nurse for a doctor or a female doctor for a nurse?
  • Do you feel more comfortable with a male or a female doctor?
  • what are your thoughts on gender stereotypes in the medical field?
  • do you think there are other areas in which gender stereotypes are seen as more of a problem?








3 comments:

  1. I personally never thought about this type of stereotype in this field of expertise. I believe the reason why is because where i come from we use two different nouns in Italian for male doctor (dottore) and female doctor (dottoressa) so this gives me an idea that there are also female doctors, while in English there's just one noun for the doctor role both male and female so its more confusing to distinguish between the gender of the person. When we say "I have an appointment with my doctor tomorrow" are we talking about a male or a female? This uncertainty gives us the presumption that we're talking about a male doctor in the most cases.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Judging my experience, I believe this stereotype is somewhat true up to an extent in American and Asian countries. Since, majority or doctors are males and majority of the nurses are females. However, this difference was not observed as much by me until you pointed it out. I believe your concern is that even at this generation women are not treated as equal as men. If this is your concern I share the same concern with you. Females in continents other than America face the most lethal phases of inequality and in order to minimize this education of both genders is the key. Education allows to break through religious barriers, to think outside the box and to achieve a sense between right and wrong.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I disagree with you at one point when you said "Of course the men have a little more say than the women but thats just how our religion entails us to do." I don't think any religion gives us a teaching on this. No religion informs us that men have more rights than the women. That's just the society's ideology that has manipulated us into believing that. But I definitely agree with the thought that there were women out there who had done great things such as, becoming a doctor. I would like to talk about my mother's aunt who was immigrated to the States from her mother country, India. She became a doctor in the era when women weren't even allowed to become one. Women were only known to serve their husbands and take care of them. When her family look at her financial life now, she is very stable and happy. Answering to one of your questions, I feel more comfortable with a female doctor than a male doctor since I'm a female myself.

    ReplyDelete